NM Supreme Court Lifts Project Jupiter Stays - The Fight Must Continue!

We wanted to share the disappointing news that today, the New Mexico Supreme Court denied New Energy Economy’s extraordinary request for a Writ of Mandamus and lifted the Temporary Stay of the Project Jupiter air-quality permitting proceeding.
Though we are very disappointed, what happened during this stay matters.
We went to the Supreme Court because we believed the rules of this proceeding were stacked against meaningful public participation. We sought a fair opportunity for the public to obtain the evidence, test the claims being made by the applicant and present its case before New Mexico decides whether to authorize an enormous new source of pollution.
That is also exactly what we told the Supreme Court:
“Due process does not guarantee merely a seat in the hearing room and an opportunity to react in real time; it guarantees a meaningful opportunity to know the case, investigate the facts, prepare the evidence, present claims and defenses, and effectively test the opposing evidence.”
The New Mexico Attorney General, a courageous group of Legislators, the Center for Biological Diversity, and the NM Environmental Law Center joined us in the effort and filed Amicus Briefs in support of our Writ with the Court.
The Supreme Court stayed the proceeding and for nearly a month, the rush stopped. The expedited hearing was vacated. With the Stay lifted, the Application's review before the Air Quality Control Commission will now proceed. But thanks to enormous public pressure - including protests by grassroots groups like FCDX, YUCCA, and Defend NM Water, sustained news coverage, and a motion filed by the New Mexico Environmental Law Center and the Center for Biological Diversity calling for the recusal of the Hearing Officer who had reversed himself several times during the proceeding - Hearing Officer Max Shepherd ultimately stepped down.

His recusal was not a judicial finding of bias, but it removed the official who had imposed the accelerated September schedule. NMED must now appoint a new Hearing Officer, who will take control of the proceeding and determine how it moves forward, including establishing a new procedural schedule. As of our writing, NMED has not appointed a replacement or held a new scheduling conference.
So while the Supreme Court has now lifted its stay, the fast-tracked process we challenged has been disrupted and slowed, and scrutiny of Project Jupiter’s permitting process has intensified.
That matters.
Slowing this process down was critical - not as an end in itself, but because speed was limiting the time available for meaningful public participation, expert review, discovery, scrutiny, and a fair and lawful process.
And on water: the Stay was also lifted but our partners succeeded in securing a Hearing
There is a separate fight underway before the New Mexico Office of the State Engineer over the groundwater being used for Project Jupiter construction.
The Center for Biological Diversity challenged the State Engineer’s authorization allowing groundwater to be pumped for the project and filed a timely protest seeking a hearing. The New Mexico Supreme Court temporarily stayed the water authorization while it considered CBD’s challenge. That stay was also lifted today.
But the underlying protest before the State Engineer remains - and there will now be a hearing.
Attorney General Raúl Torrez supported CBD’s challenge, arguing that the State Engineer had allowed groundwater pumping to continue while failing for months to schedule a hearing on the protest. The Office of the State Engineer has now publicly stated that the administrative challenges will receive a “full and fair hearing.”
That is an important development. It means the fight over Project Jupiter’s water use will move into a contested administrative process where the evidence can be put into the record, challenged, and heard.
We are deeply grateful to the Center for Biological Diversity for bringing this challenge and continuing to fight for public scrutiny of Project Jupiter’s water demands.
The Supreme Court stays have been lifted. But the scrutiny they helped create has not.
Project Jupiter’s developers spent over 7 million dollars in advertising to try to win public favor and influence the process. But we will not allow industry to railroad democracy. Our job is to make sure that speed does not replace due process, that political pressure does not replace independent decision-making, and that decisions of this magnitude are made in the open, based on evidence, with meaningful opportunities for New Mexicans to participate.
The Fight Continues!

.png)



Comments